Search

Retsch solutions for Pharma and Medtech industry

The pharmaceutical industry is a sector that focuses on researching, developing, manufacturing, and marketing drugs or pharmaceuticals. Learn more about the use of Retsch devices by clicking on the icons of each section.

Research and Development (R&D) 

Research and development involves basic research, drug discovery, preclinical testing, and clinical trials. The research to identify pharmaceutical ingredients in traditional plant medicine for example also belongs to this section. Further interesting approaches come from mechanochemistry, co-crystal and polymorph screening or nanotechnologies.

Quality Control (QC)

Quality control ensures that the manufactured pharmaceutical products meet predefined quality specifications and regulatory standards. QC activities involve rigorous testing of both the raw materials and the finished products. This includes physical, chemical, and microbiological tests to confirm that the product consistently meets the established standards of purity, potency, and safety.

Manufacturing

This involves the large-scale production of drugs that have received regulatory approval. It requires adherence to Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) to ensure product quality, safety, and efficacy. The use of bones and teeth for implant materials also has to be mentioned here as specific manufacturing application.

Special focus: Tissue homogenisation and cell disruption

Cell disruption is a crucial step, especially for the production of biopharmaceuticals. It involves breaking cells to release biologically active compounds, such as proteins, DNA, RNA, which can be used as therapeutics, vaccines, or in diagnostic applications. Homogenization of tissues like liver is another aspect of this section.

Retsch boosts Research and Development in Pharma Applications

Retsch mills are used to grind active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) and excipients to a specific particle size, which is crucial for ensuring consistent drug efficacy and bioavailability. The particle size can significantly affect the dissolution rate, absorption, and distribution of the drug within the body. Excipients, which are inactive substances formulated alongside the active ingredient of a medication, require proper sizing and homogenization to ensure they function correctly within the formulation. Special applications require nanotechnology, cocrystals or mechanosynthesis to find new APIs, both sophisticated approaches where Retsch can assist. In this section, eight different use cases with their best practises are highlighted:

In this chapter, you will learn more about:

  1. Retsch mills to grind sample material like APIs
  2. Temperature-controlled grinding to preserve temperature sensitive substances
  3. Mills used to mix the APIs with the excipients in formulation development
  4. Nanotechnology research – benefits from Retsch mills
  5. Milling plants or insects to identify ingredients
  6. Mechanochemistry for new or enhanced APIs
  7. Co-grinding, cocrystal formation and polymorph screening
  8. Metal-Organic Frameworks (MOFs) in Drug Delivery

Retsch mills to grind sample material like APIs

APIs and excipients can be pulverized in different Retsch Mills and Grinders. Depending on the substance, grinding in closed vessels is preferred as in the jars of the Retsch Ball Mills, to avoid dust formation with the highly active substances. 100 ml lactose monohydrate for example can be pulverized in a PM 100 within 1 h at 450 rpm, reducing the D90 value from 100 µm to 5 µm. The grinding was done at wet conditions, which means that the sample were mixed with 90 ml propanol.

Wet grinding is usually performed in jars of zirconium oxide, in this case 250 ml with 150 ml of 2 mm balls made of zirconium oxide. Zirconium oxide is a very abrasion resistant material, which reduces the wear in the fine grinding step which is achieved with the intense friction between the balls. With extended grinding times and smaller grinding balls, much smaller sample particles are obtainable in Retsch Planetary Ball Mill.

Pharmacologically harmless sample materials, such as starch or lactose used as excipients, can be ground in the ZM 300 or the RM 200. For instance, a 100 ml lactose sample with an initial particle size of 400 µm can be pulverized in the RM 200 to particles smaller than 100 µm within 10 minutes. Various grinding tool materials, including hard porcelain or agate, can be utilized. Larger sample quantities can be processed in the ZM 300.

Samples that tend to stick or agglomerate can be ground cryogenically using liquid nitrogen for embrittlement. The use of a cyclone is recommended. For example, 100 g of 3 mm samples were pulverized to particles smaller than 500 µm within 1 minute. Depending on the properties of the samples, the ZM 300 can also achieve a final fineness below 40 µm.

Temperature-controlled grinding to preserve temperature sensitive substances

Another example is temperature controlled wet grinding of APIs (or excipients) – here the MM 500 control or the High Energy Ball Mill Emax are beneficial. 15 g of API substance were mixed with 25 ml of Isopropanol and ground in 50 ml zirconium oxide grinding jars with 110 g of 2 mm grinding balls. The grinding process was carried out using an external chiller set to 5 °C for 30 minutes at 2000 rpm. To maintain a specific temperature range, the unique temperature mode of the Emax was utilized. The minimum temperature was set to 40 °C and the maximum to 50 °C, ensuring that grinding occurred only within this range. When the jar reached 50 °C, grinding was paused until it cooled to 40 °C, at which point grinding resumed. This special mode guarantees that the sample does not overheat during milling, with all operations, including the duration of grinding breaks, being automated.

After just 30 minutes of total process time, the original 1 mm sample was milled down to 4 µm particles. Higher fineness can be achieved by pre-grinding to less than 200 µm with 10 mm balls, followed by fine grinding with 0.5 mm balls and extended grinding time. For larger sample amounts, 125 ml grinding jars can be used. Some APIs require cryogenic grinding at -196°C, where approximately 8 g of sample can be placed in a 50 ml jar of the Cryomill. Pulverization to 100-200 µm is typically completed within 20 minutes, including pre-cooling time.

Conclusion: Retsch offers the suitable equipment to pulverize small to medium size sample quantities safely and with preservation of the temperature

Mills used to mix the APIs with the excipients in formulation development

Mixing APIs with excipients is a common topic in pharmaceutical research. Efficient mixing can be achieved using Mixer Mills, which can handle up to 6 x 20 ml samples, or Retsch Planetary Ball Mills, which offer sample volumes of up to 4 x 200 ml. For example, 196 g of starch were mixed with 4 g of pigment to demonstrate mixing efficiency. The mixture, along with 200 grinding balls of 10 mm, was placed in 500 ml grinding jars. After 5 minutes at 200 rpm, a moderate speed that ensures only mixing effects without particle crushing, the mixing was perfect.

Nanotechnology research – benefits from Retsch mills

High-energy ball mills from Retsch, like the Emax, the PM series or the MM 500 nano and control, are used in the development of nano particles. These nano formulations can offer improved drug delivery characteristics and are a growing area of interest in pharmaceutical R&D. TiO2 is used as a model substance here.

Wet and nano-scale grinding with the PM 300

Wet grinding is used to obtain particle sizes below 5 µm, as small particles tend to get charged on their surfaces and agglomerate, which makes further grinding in dry mode difficult. By adding a liquid or dispersant the particles can be kept separated.

To produce very fine particles of 100 nm or less (nano-scale grinding) by wet grinding, friction rather than impact is required. This is achieved by using a large number of small grinding balls which have a large surface and many friction points. The ideal filling level of the jar should consist of 60 % small grinding balls.

For more details on jar filling, wet grinding and sample recovery watch the video.

The video shows wet grinding in the Planetary Ball Mill PM 100.

Titanium dioxide in 125 ml Jar

The graphic shows the result of pulverizing titanium dioxide (TiO2) at 650 rpm and 800 rpm in the PM 300 and the net processing time. With the higher energy input at 800 rpm, the particle size decreases faster. However, the increased warming effects at 800 rpm should also be considered, as they might make longer breaks necessary.

Titanium dioxide in 125 ml Jar - Planetary Ball Mill PM 300

Net processing time of titanium dioxide with 0.1 mm grinding balls in sodium phosphate solution

12 g of API (15 µm particles) were mixed with 26 ml of Heptane and 110 g of 0.5 mm zirconium oxide grinding balls. This mixture was placed in a 50 ml zirconium oxide grinding jar. The grinding process was carried out in the High Energy Ball Mill Emax for 2.5 hours at 2000 rpm, resulting in a very narrow particle size distribution with a D90 value of 80 nm.

Nanoparticles smaller than 100 nm can also be produced using the MM 500 nano or MM 500 control. Typically, a grinding time of 2-3 hours at 35 Hz is required in the MM 500 nano, while the MM 500 control requires a longer grinding time at 30 Hz. The MM 500 control offers temperature regulation, allowing the jars to be counter-cooled with 4°C cold water. If the grinding medium does not freeze at zero degrees, wet grinding can also be performed at temperatures as low as -10°C to ensure the preservation of temperature-sensitive APIs.

Conclusion: Temperature-control, Nano-grinding, mixing – Retsch´s ball mills are suitable for all applications.

Milling plants or insects to identify ingredients

Plants often have natural ingredients which are useful in pharma applications, known for decades for their pharmaceutical purposes. Also other materials like insects offer some interesting compounds. The traditional Chinese medicine TCM or other traditional healing methods make use of the natural resources. Research activities aim to unreveal the API compounds in those classical plant or animal samples in order to use them as new drug and pharmaceutical substances. Depending on the initial sample size, the sample amount, the sample quantity and the required final fineness, Retsch Cutting Mills, Rotor Mills or Ball Mills are used predominantly to pulverize such samples.

Depending on the sample size and toughness, about 20 s to 3 min are required to grind up to 1 kg dried roots, fruits, stems parts and other plant materials or insects to 1-8 mm samples. Here, ideally SM 100 is used, for more robust samples like nutmeg the SM 300. A cyclone helps in any case to discharge the light samples from the grinding chamber. The ZM 300 accepts feed sizes up to 10 mm, Cutting Mills accept up to 60 mm sample pieces. For really tough materials, the 6-disc rotor instead of the parallel section rotor should be taken. Sometime finer particles than 1 mm are required- here the use of Retsch Ball mills is beneficial.

결론: Even tough or larger plant materials can be easily homogenized with Retsch Cutting Mills or Rotor Mills.

Mechanochemistry for new or enhanced APIs

Mechanochemistry, the study of chemical reactions that occur due to mechanical energy, has increasingly become a significant field of research in pharmaceuticals. This method involves inducing chemical reactions through grinding, milling, or shearing solid reactants. Mechanochemical processes offer several advantages over traditional solution-based chemistry, including reduced solvent use, enhanced reaction rates, and the ability to synthesize novel compounds. Mechanochemical reactions can be used for the synthesis of new drug molecules. This method is particularly advantageous for reactions that are difficult or inefficient in liquid solvents, allowing for the exploration of new chemical space and the potential discovery of novel therapeutic compounds. For example, the group of Professor Duncan Browne, UCL School of Pharmacy, worked on the formation of Carbon-Nitrogen bonds, a favourite process for drug discovery and development. They synthesized an intermediate in the synthesis of Vortioxetine, which is a known antidepressant [1].

Another publication of the group shows the option to use mechanochemistry in the MM 400 in direct amidation of esters [2], in just 1 h compared to 8 h in EtOH solution at 70°C. In the same paper, the synthesis of 2.4 g of the antidepressant Moclobemide in the MM 400 in just 1 h is demonstrated. Another important aspect are the various findings, that heating can improve the mechanochemical reactions, thus enabling or accelerating the reactions. Using a heat gun or heating jackets are common methods for the MM 400 as shown by the groups of Professor Ito or Professor Browne [3][4][5]. A more commercial version of temperature control and heating options is given by the MM 500 control, which also allows temperatures up to 100 °C.

Reproduced from Reference [2] with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry.

Co-grinding, cocrystal formation and polymorph screening

  1. Cocrystals consist of two or more crystalline components, typically an active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) and a coformer, in a definite stoichiometric ratio, held together by non-covalent bonds. Ball mills are used to produce pharmaceutical cocrystals, which can improve drug solubility, stability, and bioavailability without altering the molecular structure of the API.
  2. Different crystalline forms (polymorphs) of a drug can exhibit significantly different physical and chemical properties, such as solubility and melting point. Polymorph screening can help to identify stable forms of a drug that have desirable characteristics, improving drug formulation and performance.
  3. Co-grinding often refers to simultaneous grinding of an API and a (amorphous) excipients. Co-grinding can improve the solubility, stability, and bioavailability of drugs by creating fine and uniform particles and improved fluidity. The excipient can be another API, an amino acid or a polymer like cellulose or starch. Excipients as binders help hold the ingredients of a tablet together. Common fillers include lactose, mannitol, and dibasic calcium phosphate. Other excipients act as lubricants, preservatives, colouring or flavoring agents

To find the optimal coformer or excipient for an API and a specific purpose, a screening approach is typically required. Different ratios of the API and the other substance need to be investigated, resulting in numerous combination options. Since substances can be very expensive, the screening is usually performed on a small scale. The special screening adapter for planetary ball mills can significantly aid this process by using disposable vials, such as 1.5 ml GC glass vials. The adapter features 24 positions arranged in an outer ring with 16 positions and an inner ring with 8 positions. The outer ring can hold up to 16 vials, allowing for the screening of up to 64 samples simultaneously with exact same energy input conditions when using the Planetary Ball Mill PM 400. In total, 96 samples can be screened in one batch. First upscaling trial can be done in the adapter capable of keeping 7 x 20 ml glass vials.

Retsch also offers systems for upscaling co-crystal formation, such as the Drum Mill TM 300. This mill meets the demands of modern pharmaceutical manufacturing, as demonstrated by the mechanochemical synthesis of rac-Ibuprofen:Nicotinamide co-crystals. In just 90 minutes, 3.2 kg of co-crystals were produced with a 99 % yield, using minimal amounts of ethanol in the LAG process. Notably, the metal abrasion was minimal, with measured values well below concerning levels. [6]

Metal-Organic Frameworks (MOFs) in Drug Delivery

MOFs are coordination networks with organic ligands and metal ion nodes. They have a high surface area and tunable porosity, making them excellent candidates for drug delivery systems. Mechanochemistry is used to synthesize MOFs that can encapsulate drugs, providing controlled release and targeted delivery mechanisms. Here, the use of thermically controlled mills is very useful. If for example the MM 500 control is used with a chiller, the temperature can be lowered so that intermediates of the chemical reactions can be stabilized and thus the yield of those substances is drastically increased. With the right choice of the milling instrument, completely different educts can be obtained!

Easy Sample Preparation for Quality Control

In quality control laboratories, Retsch mills prepare samples for various analytical techniques, such as High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC), Spectrophotometry, and Dissolution testing. Proper sample preparation is key to accurate and reliable analysis. The precise and reliable performance of Retsch Mills and Crushers makes them indispensable tools for various QC applications:

Grinding tablets, pills and dragees with Retsch mills – easy and straight forward

Retsch mills are widely used in the pharmaceutical industry for grinding pills, dragees, and tablets to achieve the desired particle size and consistency. These mills ensure that the active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) and excipients are uniformly processed, which is crucial for the efficacy and safety of the final product. One of the key advantages of using Retsch mills is their ability to work with different grinding tool materials such as steel for standard applications or zirconium oxide for avoiding metal abrasion – which could disturb the analytics later on (increase heavy metal content).

For instance, the PM 100 planetary ball mill can pulverize 20 x 20 mm pills in a 125 ml jar zirconium oxide with 7x 20 ml balls, zirconium oxide, in 2 min at 450 rpm. The final particle size is about 150 µm. This mill is preferred for larger pills, larger sample volumes and grinding prior to heavy metal analysis, as the jars made of zirconium oxide are available up to 500 ml. The MM 400 is the ideal ball mill to grind small sample portions. For example, 10 x 10 mm pills can be ground easily within 2 min at 30 Hz in a 50 ml jar stainless steel with a 25 ml ball. The final fineness is comparable to that in the PM 100. Jars of zirconium oxide are available up to a size of 35 ml.

In the ZM 300, same pills can be ground much faster in just a few seconds. Usually ring sieves around 0.5 mm or finer are used, as well as the standard 12 teeth rotor. Grinding is performed at about 18000 rpm. Depending on the sample, the final fineness can be in a range less than 10 µm, but usually 200-400 µm are obtained.

ERWEKA is a leading manufacturer of tablet testing equipment for the pharmaceutical industry. With more than 65 years of experience, ERWEKA develops innovative solutions for large pharmaceutical and life science companies, research and test laboratories, as well as universities all over the world. ERWEKA stands for excellent product quality, attractive design, user-friendly operation and reliable performance.

Reproducible Particle size analysis with Retsch sieving machines

Retsch sieving machines are renowned for their precision and reliability in various industries, including pharmacy. These machines are essential for particle size analysis, ensuring that materials meet the stringent quality standards required in pharmaceutical applications. The AS 200 control and AS 200 jet are two notable models in Retsch's lineup. The AS 200 control is a vibratory sieve shaker that offers precise control over sieving parameters, making it ideal for quality control and research and development in the pharmaceutical industry. It features an electromagnetic drive that ensures consistent sieving results, and its digital controls allow for the storage of up to 99 sieving programs, ensuring reproducibility and compliance with ISO 9001 guidelines.

On the other hand, the AS 200 jet is an air jet sieving machine designed for the efficient dispersion and deagglomeration of fine powders. This model is particularly suitable for pharmaceutical materials that require precise particle size distribution. Unlike the vibratory sieving method used by the AS 200 control, the AS 200 jet employs a rotating air jet that disperses and deagglomerates fine powders more effectively. This air jet creates a vacuum that pulls the particles through the sieve, ensuring that even the finest particles are separated efficiently. Thus, the sample may be “finer” when analysed with the air jet sieving machine. This can be seen for example with a fine powder sample. Test sieves with mesh sizes 40, 75, 125 and 150 µm were used. The AS 200 control was operated at an amplitude of 1.2 mm with 10 s interval function, over 5 min. The AS 200 jet was operated in the Swiss Mode with a speed of 55 rpm and a negative pressure of 30 mbar – the total procedure also required 5 min work.

In pharmaceutical applications, these sieving machines are used to ensure the uniformity, stability, and purity of drug formulations. Accurate particle size analysis is crucial for determining the dissolution rate, bioavailability, and overall efficacy of pharmaceutical products.

결론: Retsch sieving machines are most suitable to assure quality control – whether we are talking about incoming inspection of raw materials, results of R&D trials or production control of substances in manufacturing.

Retsch Benefits for Pharmaceutical Manufacturing and GMP

Steel 316L is widely used in pharmaceutical manufacturing due to its hygienic properties and exceptional resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion. It is a low carbon grade of stainless steel that offers excellent resistance to high temperatures and chemical corrosion. This makes it ideal for applications that require frequent sanitation and low chemical reactivity. Retsch offers some mills in 316L to meet those specific requirements in the pharmaceutical manufacturing.

Pilot-scale grinding of plant materials prior to extraction

The Cutting Mill SM 300 316L foodGrade version is designed for contamination-free cutting of raw materials for the food and medical industries. All parts in contact with the sample are made of 316 L stainless steel or FDA-certified stainless steel, ensuring contamination-free processing. It is equipped with a long-stock hopper for easy feeding of materials like cannabis plant parts or other dried plant materials, herbs and spices. The ground samples can be either used directly in pharmaceutical applications or used for extraction via ethanol or supercritical CO2. The mill's powerful 3 kW drive with high torque and RES technology ensures excellent grinding results, even for tough jobs where other cutting mills fail. The variable speed allows for perfect adaptation to application requirements, and a range of bottom sieves with aperture sizes from 0.25 to 20 mm ensures a defined final fineness.

CoCrystal sysnthesis in kilogram scale

Retsch drum mills, such as the TM 300, are used for the mechanochemical synthesis of pharmaceutical co-crystals in kilogram scale. This method is environmentally friendly and efficient, reducing energy consumption and minimizing environmental impact as hardly any solvents are used. For example, the TM 300 was used to produce 3.2 kg of rac-Ibuprofen:Nicotinamide co-crystals in just 90 minutes with a purity of 99%. [6]

The TM 500 316L is a laboratory ball mill designed to grind large sample volumes up to 35 l. It accepts initial feed sizes of up to 20 mm and can achieve grind sizes down to 15 µm by friction and impact. The TM 500 316L is particularly suitable for applications where the sample must not be contaminated in any way. It features a stainless steel 316L drum and hopper, ensuring contamination-free processing. The mill's variable speed ranges from 10 to 50 rpm, making it adaptable to different application requirements. The TM 500 316L is equipped with an electronic tilt function for easy emptying and programmable grinding breaks to process heat-sensitive sample materials.

드럼 밀 TM 500 : 스테인레스 스틸 드럼 316L foodGrade 버전
스테인레스 스틸 드럼 316L foodGrade 버전

Production of material suitable for bone implant

Using bones as material for bone implants is a highly effective approach in medical implants. Natural bone materials, such as autografts and allografts, are commonly used due to their excellent biocompatibility and ability to integrate with the patient's existing bone. These materials provide a natural scaffold that promotes bone regeneration and healing. Overall, the use of bones as material for bone implants offers a reliable and effective solution for bone repair and regeneration. The process of preparing bone materials for implants involves grinding and pulverizing the bone to achieve the desired particle size and consistency. Various milling techniques, such as those offered by Retsch mills, are employed to ensure the bone material is processed efficiently and safely.

Especially Cutting Mills are used to pre-grind larger sample quantities if required. Fine grinding steps are carried out in Ultra Centrifugal mill ZM 300 or Ball Mills like MM 400 or the CryoMill. Using first the SM 300 and then the ZM 300, about 800 g bones can be fine ground to less than 200 µm in about 25 min.

Sieve analysis in pharmaceutical production

Retsch sieve shakers are essential tools in pharmaceutical production for ensuring precise particle size analysis. The AS 200 control and AS 200 jet models are particularly notable, with the former offering precise control over sieving parameters and the latter being ideal for fine powders due to its air jet dispersion method. These machines help maintain the uniformity, stability, and purity of drug formulations, which are crucial for determining the dissolution rate, bioavailability, and overall efficacy of pharmaceutical products. Additionally, Retsch sieve shakers comply with ISO 9001 guidelines, ensuring reproducibility and high-quality results.

The Retsch EasySieve software is a powerful tool for particle size analysis in pharmaceutical production. It automates the registration, evaluation, and administration of measurement data, making the sieving process more efficient and accurate. The software features a logical design and self-explanatory measurement protocols, transforming complex data into charts and tables. EasySieve CFR, a version of the software, offers compliance with FDA 21 CFR Part 11, ensuring data integrity and security. The software also includes an integrated AuditTrail for consistent documentation of every working step of the sieving process, and all data is stored in encrypted form in databases. The AuditTrail Manager provides three different user levels, from administrator to standard user.

Special focus cell disruption and tissue homogenisation

DNA, RNA, and proteins play crucial roles in the development of innovative therapies and diagnostics. DNA technology, particularly recombinant DNA, enables the production of therapeutic proteins such as insulin and growth hormones, which are essential for treating various genetic disorders. RNA-based therapeutics, including mRNA vaccines and RNA interference (RNAi) therapies, offer promising approaches for targeting specific genes and treating diseases like cancer and viral infections. Proteins, on the other hand, are used as biopharmaceuticals, including monoclonal antibodies and enzymes, which are vital for treating a wide range of conditions. These biomolecules are integral to advancing personalized medicine. Cell disruption using bead beating is a widely used mechanical method for breaking cells to release their intracellular components like DNA or proteins. This technique involves mixing the cell suspension with beads made of glass and then agitating the mixture to create shearing forces that crack the cell walls. Bead beating is effective for a variety of cell types, including bacteria, yeast, fungi, and algae. It is particularly advantageous because it can process multiple samples simultaneously without the risk of cross-contamination and does not require the addition of chemicals that might interfere with subsequent extraction steps. The process can be performed on a small scale using 2 ml single-use vials or on a larger scale with 50 ml disposable Falcon tubes. For example, the Mill MM 400, equipped with different adapters, can efficiently disrupt cells in both small and large volumes, making it a versatile tool for laboratory applications.

The CryoMill is an excellent tool for cell disruption using larger grinding balls, especially for samples that are sensitive to heat. By cooling the material in the grinding jar to -196°C with liquid nitrogen, the CryoMill ensures that the integrity of proteins and other cellular components is preserved during the disruption process. With the MM 500 control, up to 2 x 20 ml cell suspension can be processed cryogenically (temperature range from 0 °C to – 100°C) or just in a cooled way, for example at 10°C.

Retsch equipment also offer solution for the homogenisation of tissue samples like liver or skin. Again, such samples can be homogenized in 2 ml or 5 ml Eppendorf tubes or in 50 ml Falcon tubes.

Liver sample before and after homogenization in the MM 400

This section is derived from the following page:

References

[1] Group of Professor Duncan L. Browne, Department of Pharmaceutical and Biological Chemistry, University College London: Robust Buchwald-Hartwig amination enabled by ball-milling; Org. Biolol. Chem. 2019, 17, 1722 DOI: 10.1039/c8ob01781f

[2] Group of Professor Duncan L. Browne, Department of Pharmaceutical and Biological Chemistry, University College London: Direct Amidation of Esters by Ball Milling; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2021, 60, 21868-21874; doi.org/10.1002/anie.202106412
[3] Group of Professor Hajime Ito, Division of Applied Chemistry, Faculty of Engineering, Hokkaido University: Solvent-free zinc-mediated Bechamp reduction using mechanochemistry; DOI: 10.1039/d4mr00138a
[4] Group of Professor Hajime Ito, Division of Applied Chemistry, Faculty of Engineering, Hokkaido University: Solid-state aromatic nucleophilic fluorination: a rapid, practical, and environmentally friendly route to N-heteroaryl fluorides; Green Chem., 2025, 27, 1771; DOI: 10.1039/d4gc06362g
[5] Group of Professor Duncan L. Browne, Department of Pharmaceutical and Biological Chemistry, University College London: Temperature-Controlled Mechanochemistry for the Nickel-Catalyzed Suzuki-Miyaura Coupling of Aryl Sulfomates via Ball Milling and Twin-Screw Extrusion; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2022, 61, e202210508; doi.org/10.1002/anie.202210508
[6] Jan-Hendrik Schöbel, Frederik Winkelmann, Joel Bicker, and Michael Felderhoff; Mechanochemical kilogram-scale synthesis of rac:ibuprofen:nicotinamide co-crystals using a drum mill; RSC Mechanochemistry, 2025, DOI: 10.1039/D4MR00096J